skip navigation

Stillwater's Allison Benning is the Star Tribune's Metro Player of the Year

By JIM PAULSEN, Star Tribune, 06/14/21, 4:00PM CDT


With a fastball clocked at 69 mph, the Ponies' ace dominates hitters with a speed few peers can attain while also relying on a well-developed pitching IQ.

“She’s the best player I’ve ever coached. It’s not just her talent, it’s her focus. She’s so mentally strong.” -- Stillwater softball coach Angie Ryan on senior Allison Benning

Photo: Cheryl A. Myers, SportsEngine

Let’s start at 43 feet, the distance in softball from the pitching rubber to home plate.

When Stillwater senior pitcher Allison Benning, 6-1 with endless legs and long, whip-like arms that generate velocity and spin, finishes her windup and releases the ball, it leaves her hand about 8 feet closer to the plate.

It doesn’t take long to reach home. Hitters rarely have a chance.

“I just look intimidating, people have told me,” Benning said. “Plus my arms being long helps me throw faster. And I can get out further and push harder because of my long legs. I’m probably a foot or two closer to the plate than most girls.”

It doesn’t hurt Benning’s résumé that the ball is thrown at a speed few can attain. Her fastball has been clocked at 69 mph, and that was more than a year ago. It’s entirely possible she’s topped 70 this season, the equivalent to throwing a baseball in the upper 90s.

“I don’t know if I’ve reached 70. Maybe. I feel a little stronger this year,” she said.

After four seasons as a varsity starter for the Ponies — it would be five if not for COVID-19 — Benning’s remarkable high school career comes to a close this week, when she leads Stillwater into the state tournament for a third consecutive season.

The Star Tribune’s 2021 Metro Player of the Year pitched the Ponies to the Class 4A championship as a freshman, unexpected because the team was below .500 before the postseason. That performance served as her coming-out party, announcing herself as a premier pitcher in the metro.

“That was awesome,” she said. “There’s nothing better than that.”

The next year, Stillwater made it to the Class 2A championship game, falling a run short. Benning was named Gatorade Minnesota Player of the Year.

Back after the 2020 stoppage, Benning has looked every bit the ace. She doesn’t just throw hard, she locates pitches well, changes speeds and has a well-developed pitching IQ.

“Throwing 70 right down the middle, good hitters can still hit that,’’ she said. “I’d rather throw 68, 69 and hit the corners.”

Allison Benning pitched earlier this year in a game against Elk River. Photo: Earl J. Ebensteiner, SportsEngine

She’s been compared to Montana Fouts, the 6-1 pitcher at Alabama who recently pitched a perfect game in the Women’s College World Series.

“When I heard that, I was like, ‘OK, cool, whatever.’ ” Benning said. “Then I watched her as a freshman and I thought, ‘Wow. They’re comparing me to this girl?’ That’s the best compliment I’ve ever gotten.”

Her stats this season attest to her dominance. She’s 15-1 with a 1.07 ERA and 151 strikeouts. Some may have bigger numbers, but Stillwater’s talent allows coach Angie Ryan to spell her star pitcher, shifting her to first base and allowing junior Keira Murphy, a talented pitcher in her own right, to step forward.

“We’re lucky to have two pitchers this good,” Ryan said.

While pitching is where Benning’s future lies — she’s signed with Oregon, a perennial top-20 program — she’s just as dangerous at the plate. She’s hitting .508 with 13 home runs and 36 RBI.

Ryan, a softball lifer who has excelled as both a player and a coach, says simply: “She’s the best player I’ve ever coached. It’s not just her talent, it’s her focus. She’s so mentally strong.”

Benning’s father, Mike, played softball and introduced her to it when she was young.

“I thought, ‘This is OK, this is fun. I want to keep doing this,’ ” she recalled. A few years later, when she was about 9 or 10 years old, she knew softball was her life’s passion.

“I was thinking, ‘I love this. I want to play college softball.’ ”

There have been numerous camps, plenty of top-notch training and lots of attention. Most recently, she’s been training with former Gophers All-America pitcher Sara Moulton, who owns and runs Strike Zone Sports in Eagan. She has outgrown local softball clubs and now plays for Top Gun Fastpitch out of Kansas City, a nationally prominent program that draws top talent from around the country.

Extra Inning Softball, a website that ranks the top players in the nation, has Benning at No. 13 overall and No. 8 among pitchers in the Class of 2021.

A bright future lies ahead, to be sure, but first things first: There’s a state tournament to attend to.

“I love representing my school, and this is the last chance I’ll get to play with girls I’ve played with since I was 8 years old,” she said. “I want to win another one.”

Past Star Tribune Metro Players of the Year

2020: no season
2019: Ava Dueck, Maple Grove
2018: Emily Hansen, Buffalo
2017: Marybeth Olson, Chanhassen
2016: Katelyn Kemmetmueller, Rogers
2015: Sydney Smith, Maple Grove
2014: Smith (junior)
2013: Hannah Heacox, Stillwater
2012: Cayli Sadler, Maple Grove
2011: Hayley Nybo, Hopkins
2010: Sara Moulton, Eagan
2009: Moulton (junior)
2008: Sam Hildebrandt, Park of Cottage Grove
2007: Brynne Dordel, Chaska
2006: Kristin Danielson, Mounds View
2005: Briana Hassett, Eastview
2004: Chrissy Sward, North St. Paul
2003: Allison Bakke, Anoka (junior)
2002: Kristen Schmidt, Park of Cottage Grove
2001: Missy Beseres, Armstrong
2000: Lyn Peyer (junior), Minnetonka
1999: Angie Recknor, Hopkins
1998: Recknor (junior)
1997: Lacey Hughes, Wayzata
1996: Karissa Hoehn, Stillwater
1995: Erika Kanavati, Henry Sibley
1994: Laura Peters, Park of Cottage Grove
1993: Tracy Carey, Richfield
1992: Laura LeVander, Woodbury
1991: Jeanette Strubb, St. Bernard’s
1990: Karyn Valentino, St. Bernard’s
1989: Sue Varland, North St. Paul
1988: Michelle DeBace, St. Bernard’s


Softball Hub Headlines